Reviewer Resources
TLCSD asks reviewers for the journal to use the same feedback form for all types of submission (e.g., data-based research, reflections, student voices). Items 1-3 on the feedback form should be completed for all manuscripts, as they focus on the purpose, description of context, and connection to existing evidence which are crucial for all types of manuscripts. Items 4-6 focus on data collection, analysis, and interpretation and are completed ONLY for manuscripts where qualitative, quantitative, or mixed methods data are reported. Items 7 and 8 focus on scholarly synthesis of information presented in non-data-based manuscripts.
